What did you think of the Return Of Jafar reference? It's one of the funniest jokes I've ever written, and I said to myself sadly "Nobody will actually get it. Except Chris. This joke is basically for him."
That joke definitely made me chuckle.
I have Gilda and Bernadette pick on Augatha unfairly because it's subversive. I'm basically making Gilda and Bernadette the bad guys in their relationship which is provocative. At one point I was like "You know what, this might be a bad idea because it makes them both look so bad." But after awhile I was like "I am perfectly willing to make Gilda and Bernadette look bad." They are NOT perfect characters, and I'm not going to water down or gussy up their personalities to make the reader like them more. It's totally in character they both suck about this one thing.
I don't think it makes them look that bad, I mean, it is Augatha, and them not being perfect is a good thing.
The sitting around and watching TV elements of The Un-Iverse are just as integral to the franchise as the so-called adventures. I would argue they are even MORE relevant, because despite their jokey nature, they are where the actual character development can be seen. Comic book fans are NOT The Un-Iverse's target audience and nowhere is that more clear than the fact that half of The Un-Iverse is basically the characters farting around with each other.
I really like the fact that you have sort of a comic strip sensibility (as opposed to comic book), and that certainly came out in the One Shots and Tales issues. I liked the Piranha vs. Raggleworth traps short, it makes them unique, but the way the TV stuff was placed in this issue made me sort of say "Get on with it already".
The Un-Iverse does not as a rule engage in tropes where characters switch bodies or temporarily get into situations like that that have to be put right by the end of the issue like Gilda becoming a Dog. All of the characters are in their set personas and situations throughout the entire series' run (although I WILL be using the power switching trope for ONE issue in Lace Doilies). Mostly it's for the characters to always be responsible for their own actions.
I didn't mean for them to actually switch, I just meant if we would ever see, say, Meek speculate what Gilda would be like if she were a dog or he a cat.
This is the problem with each issue being a chapter. The Piranha DOES ask the Man in Pajamas the Riddle soon enough, and there is actual fall-out from that. Because there is fall-out from that character being asked, it was the wrong place for the Piranha to ask it. And the real reason he doesn't ask is the same reason he can fly the spaceship. He can SENSE there is fall-out coming, and isn't ready to deal with it. It's easier for him to randomly ask the Riddle of people he can guess they don't know it. On some very real level, he doesn't actually want to know the answer. The thing he wants most is also the thing he wants least.
That's really interesting, and definitely hinted at when Piranha confronts Augatha. I like that he has to know but dreads the answer. I didn't get it from this instance, though, it just felt like it wasn't important to him.
More issues...
Once again, I'm digging these UnComix Tale Interludes. You have a large universe, it works as catching breaths between arcs. And since Gilda and Meek are present in these, I prefer them to One Shots. That isn't to say I didn't enjoy the Howler and Narf-Narf and Chirp stories, those were fun.
Bad parent or not, Meek would have been a total wet blanket if he had said no to Bernadette's Halloween adventure. The fact that ghosts have such a mundane weakness that is part of Halloween culture makes sense in a funny way. And since Donna Demented was present, that story still had its horrific aspect.
Warlocks Beyond Reality arc - I'm glad we're getting back to Meek's vanishing power and having thosee nightmares, that was a definitely a thread I wanted to be followed up on.
Do we need multiple names for BS detector (everyone seems to call it that)? It didn't occur to me Gilda would know something is up with Meek and Bernadette after the baseball bat incident because I didn't think it works that way. The Narrator mentions Bernadette hates and loves Gilda, so isn't that her standard mood, as established by Augatha's truth spear? Would Gilda necessarily know something was up with Bernadette now? Gilda knows Bob is untrustworthy but is still telling the truth. It's more than just detecting BS, there are intuitive and empathic powers as well. Bob kind of looks like Thwomp from Mario Bros.
Gilda is really terrible around children, and she makes things worse for Bernadette by giving in to her inner rascal and Bernadette is scared by what she saw in the dungeon. It's also messed up when Gilda says nobody likes her.
The Warlocks arc improved Meek's character for me by leaps and bounds, and I can finally put a finger on what I like about him and what he brings to the table. Meek is the character you like rooting for. Gilda you can't really root for in the same way because it's established that the Universe loves her and you get a sense she'll come out on top, while Meek seems insignificant in comparison. It's actually kind of like Gilda is the Superman and Meek is the Jimmy Olson. I love seeing the fact that Meek's character and skills are put to the test when he is completely in over his head. He has learned a lot from his time adventuring with Gilda.
I like the Tick reference with the Moon, but it was distracting in many of the panels (particularly the ones that are supposed to be closer shots).
You mention in the Linear notes that days and nights on the Plain are shorter, but I'm having trouble following the sequence of events because you have A) Meek's mission B) Augatha with the Psycow C) Gilda and Bernadette at Mt. Crushmore and D) Vic Puff's election. Is Augatha asleep for that entire time Meek has been on the plain? Many days pass during this. We see later Bob talking about time travel, but how does that work with Meek and Augatha's situations?
I kind of hate that Gilda and Bernadette oversleep. They're in a very dangerous place, and they have communication with Raggleworth for support, so couldn't they have set an alarm or kept him in the loop or something?
The Balls-Out Void was cool. You may say it's nothing special, and it has been done before, but I really like the art.
Having Bernadette react to the tastes and pop culture of an older generation is a great use of the character, but I need to go on a little tangent here. In the Linear notes you say that objectively speaking Futurama is better than the Simpsons and Gilda could rather break somebody else's bones than admit that. While it's perfectly fine to prefer Simpsons over Futurama or vice versa, they are both amazing shows, there really is no way to judge them objectively. Basically it's debatable and comes down to personal preference, and I think it's odd that Gilda felt so threatened or even frightened by Bernadette's rant about Generation X and their tastes. Bernadette knows a lot but she hasn't lived through much, she doesn't know what it's like to witness firsthand something like, say, cassettes and mixed tapes being replaced by playlists and iPods. I feel like when she says something along the lines of Quantum Leap being the best Gilda's generation can do, Gilda's response would be to smile and say "Get back to me when you're my age looking back on today." Society and pop culture are ever growing and evolving, and Bernadette may be advanced, but kids' personal tastes and sensibilities change too.
How big is Augatha? I always thought she was taller and even bulkier than Meek, but in many of these panels, they look the same size. I do like the new expressions you've given Augatha here, we haven't really seen her this distressed. At the same time, I love the look on her face when she beheads the Psycow.
Great use of the Narrator with Meek bringing Augatha to the top of the cliff. It's sad when Meek realizes he and Augatha have been through a traumatizing experience and he
still has to throw her off the cliff.
You suggest Meek taking the hand from evil Meek, but I'm wondering if Meek could have taken zombie Meek's hand. Either before or after he became a zombie?
Is there some sort of OWL Gilda or someone needs to pass to go from Novice to Sorceress?
Finally, I have to bring up the shipping issue because this arc changed the way I saw Meek in a certain respect. Meek and Gilda always struck me as platonic, even when they were at the club and even when Gilda had Meek put on that underwear to send to Augatha (I thought it was just a gag, but you do have a point about it being sexually humiliating). The thing is, this story CLEARLY establishes Meek as a being with sexual desires. In this arc you have Meek react pleasantly to seeing alternate versions of him and Gilda being romantic, him alluding to having a favorite activity with his left hand, and his sexual tension with Augatha. There are clear parallels with his relationship with Gilda and Augatha here, they even have a heart to heart conversation (does anything end up coming from that, by the way?) . I can see Meek and Augatha taking a "Whatever happens on the Whahuma Plain, stays on the Whahuma Plain" attitude, but if I start seeing Meek as having an unrequited crush on Gilda, I'm going to start feeling sorry for him in a way I didn't think I was supposed to based on how their friendship initially formed.