"Steamboat Willie" (1928) vs. "A Wild Hare" (1940)

Latest News

Which character had the better debut short?

  • "Steamboat Willie" (1928)

    Votes: 2 66.7%
  • "A Wild Hare" (1940)

    Votes: 1 33.3%

  • Total voters
    3

TheDaveMaybe

Film buff, film critic, and aspiring filmmaker
May 5, 2016
39
Ratings
21
8
23
Oregon, United States
#1
The age-old question, which was the better debut cartoon short: Mickey Mouse's "Steamboat Willie" from 1928, or Bugs Bunny's "A Wild Hare" from 12 years later? Me personally, Bugs is the better character, but "Steamboat Willie" is a masterpiece, so I have to give it to "Steamboat".
 
#3
It's like comparing apples to oranges. Both are great cartoons. They were made a little more than a decade apart. They were also made by two different studios. Disney focused more on personality and emotion in his cartoons whereas Warners was more on comedy. I would say for those reasons, both are great in their own ways.
 

Copaci

A Cartoon and Logos Fan
Mar 19, 2017
848
Ratings
308 9
43
15
Romania
#4
I like A Wild Hare more than Steamboat Willie because it has loads of comedy and hunting action and I even liked that scene where Elmer was crying when he thought he killed Bugs. That makes a very great Looney Tunes/Merrie Melodies cartoon. Regarding Steamboat Willie, I'm not into it that much, but I like that scene where Mickey Mouse whistles in the boat (it also appears on the current Walt Disney Animation Studios logo).
 
Last edited:

Spotlight

Staff online

Latest profile posts

All right! Profile posts are back! Now what was I talking about?
Alright, @RandomMe. I'll bite. What's DC PT?
It's a shame that while you Americans keep age-old televised Halloween traditions, here in Portugal they have since been abnegated (I'm talking to you, DC PT).
Great Pumpkin is on tonight! (The edited version)
My Hero Academia: The Two Heroes is finally in my region's cinemas!