Sweet profile pic! I just popped in that album again recently and loved every second of it. I was actually planning on seeing them live with Toxic Holocaust a couple months ago, but I had a job interview out of town that got in the way :/
And now for the first matchup of round 1. It's Alternate Universe Christmas Tales. The matchup is between the My Little Pony episode "A Hearth's Warming Tail" to the Sesame Street special "Once Upon A Sesame Street Christmas".